Asking Clients for Reviews: Scripts That Do Not Feel Awkward

Law firm reviews shape who gets the next call, yet most attorneys feel awkward asking for them. The work is confidential, clients may have been through something painful, and nobody wants to sound like a salesperson at the end of a matter. The good news is that a short, well-timed request rarely feels awkward to the client. Below are the moments to ask, five scripts you can adapt, and how to reply to reviews without breaching confidentiality.

When to Ask

Timing matters more than wording. The best moments are:

  • When a matter is resolved well and the client is relieved.
  • When a client thanks you, by email, card or phone.
  • At the final meeting or call, when you hand over documents or explain next steps.
  • A few days after a settlement or closing, once the client has had time to absorb the result.

Avoid asking while a matter is still active, in the middle of a dispute about fees, or when a client is clearly still distressed. A later, gentler request is always better than an early, awkward one.

Check Your Rules First

Lawyer advertising rules vary by state. Some states have specific rules on testimonials, and all of them prohibit misleading statements. Never offer anything in return for a review, including discounts or gifts, and never ask staff, friends or family to post reviews. Google’s own policies prohibit incentives and fake reviews as well, so the two sets of rules point the same way.

Five Scripts That Work

1. At the final meeting

“I am really glad this worked out. Many of our clients find us by reading reviews, so if you felt we helped, a short Google review would mean a lot. You do not need to mention any details of your case. I will send you the link by email so it only takes a minute.”

2. The follow-up email

“Thank you again for trusting us with your matter. If you have a moment, would you share a few words about your experience on Google? Here is the direct link: [link]. A sentence or two is plenty, and please do not include details about your case. Either way, it was a privilege to help.”

3. The short text message

“Hi [first name], it is [attorney] from [firm]. Thanks again for working with us. If you are happy to, here is the link for a quick Google review: [link]. No case details needed.”

4. When a client thanks you in writing

“Thank you, that means a great deal to the whole team. Would you be comfortable sharing something similar on Google? It helps people in a similar situation find us. Here is the link: [link].”

5. For sensitive matters

In family, criminal and other sensitive matters, be extra careful. Make the request optional, say clearly that a short review without any details is enough, and accept a “no” gracefully.

“Only if you feel comfortable: a brief review about how we communicated and supported you would help others find us. Please keep any details of your situation private. It is completely fine to say no.”

Make It Easy to Say Yes

  • Use a direct link that opens the review form, not your website or profile page.
  • Send one reminder at most, about a week later, and then stop.
  • Make it part of the routine. Add the request to your matter closing checklist so it happens every time, not only when someone remembers.
  • Say thank you when a review appears, privately or with a short public reply.

Reviews also need somewhere to work. A strong profile and a site that shows reviews next to the right practice areas turn them into consultations. That is part of every law firm website design project I build and a core piece of law firm SEO.

Replying Without Breaking Confidentiality

Responding to reviews is where attorneys face the greatest risk. The ABA Journal’s coverage of ABA Formal Opinion 496 explains that a negative online review does not permit a lawyer to reveal confidential client information, and that lawyers should seriously consider not responding at all.

For positive reviews, a short thank-you that adds no details is safe. For negative ones, if you reply, keep it generic, for example: “Professional obligations do not allow me to respond as I would wish. Please contact me directly so we can discuss your concerns.” Never confirm or describe the matter, and never argue publicly.

Mistakes to Avoid

  • Offering gifts, discounts or anything else in exchange for a review.
  • Writing reviews for clients or posting them from the office.
  • Asking only after a big win and never after ordinary matters, which makes reviews arrive in rare bursts.
  • Replying to criticism with details of the case.
  • Sending repeated reminders to a client who has not responded.

If your reviews are growing but calls are not, the problem is usually elsewhere, often in which searches your pages target. My guide to long-tail law firm keywords covers that side.

Law Firm Reviews FAQ

Is it ethical for lawyers to ask clients for reviews?

In general, yes, as long as you follow your state’s advertising rules, offer nothing in return and do not tell clients what to write. Asking satisfied clients to share an honest experience is widely accepted. Check your state bar’s guidance on testimonials, especially if you plan to display reviews on your website.

Should we ask every client for a review?

Ask every client whose matter has closed, unless the circumstances make it inappropriate. Asking consistently, rather than only after the best outcomes, produces a steady flow of honest reviews, which readers trust more than a handful of perfect ones, and it keeps your profile looking active.

What if a client wants to stay anonymous?

Respect that. Many clients in sensitive matters prefer not to be publicly associated with a law firm. Thank them for their kind words privately and do not push. A steady flow from clients who are comfortable sharing is enough to build a strong profile over time.

Final Word

A review request takes thirty seconds and can shape your firm’s next hundred calls. Ask at the right moment, keep it short, never offer anything in return and reply with confidentiality first. To see how your firm’s online presence looks to a potential client, send your site for a free mini audit and get three quick wins within 48 hours.

Rubel SBS, founder of Rankicon

Written by

Rubel SBS

Rubel SBS is the founder of Rankicon and has been an SEO consultant since 2010. He has delivered 1,500+ projects for clients in 76 countries and writes these guides from hands-on work on real websites.

Leave a Comment